Law Office of Allan E. Dunaway, PLC

Reformed bankruptcy laws not helping creditors

The lobbyists for credit card companies have been successful, in some ways. Not only were they able to get Congress to pass the Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act of 2005 (BAPCPA), but they created the impression in many people that it was the Bankruptcy System that encouraged many people to file personal bankruptcy.

In their caricature, the average debtor spent wildly, accumulated massive debt and then would file a bankruptcy to get rid of their debt, presumably, so they could start the process all over again. So, the BAPCPA was designed to prevent this "abuse" and allow creditors to receive more of their debt back from these abusive debtors. Eight years after the BAPCPA was passed, has this happened?

Sadly, no. A recent study backed by the American Bankruptcy Institute has found that creditors have done worse under the BAPCPA. We work with many clients here in Louisville, and our experience has always been that most debtors are in bankruptcy because they are out of other options.

As the author of the study notes, "The theory that there are can-pay debtors lurking in the shadows was not confirmed by the data." She even suggested that the credit lobby knew recoveries would not be helped, but that they wanted to create a "sweat box" for debtors that would prevent them from filing bankruptcy.

Devices like the "means test" were designed to limit debtors' ability to file a Chapter 7, and force more into Chapter 13. The amended law also increased the cost of filing. And while these changes may make it more difficult for individual debtors, it has not increased payments to creditors.

Why? The simple answer is that individuals who file bankruptcy do so because they are financially tapped out, not because they are clever at hatching financial fraud schemes. We will leave that to Wall Street.

Source: Bloomberg, "Study Finds 2005 Code Reform Cut Recoveries: Bankruptcy," Bill Rochelle, November 26, 2013

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Contact the Firm

Get Sound Advice In A Free Consultation

For sound bankruptcy advice you can count on, from a skilled lawyer who truly cares about your future, contact the Louisville Law Office of Allan E. Dunaway, PLC. We have two convenient locations: Louisville, Kentucky, and Jeffersonville, Indiana. Our main office in Louisville is located off the beaten path so you won't have to deal with downtown traffic and can pull right up to our door and walk right in.

Call us at 502-785-1005, or send an email message. Our law firm welcomes the opportunity to serve you in any way we can.

If for some reason personal bankruptcy is not for you, if you do not qualify for the Chapter 7 approach via the "means test" and Chapter 13 reorganization is not the answer, Allan E. Dunaway works hard to inform you of other appropriate means of debt settlement that suits your unique needs.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Kentucky Office

Indiana Office

714 Lyndon Lane
Suite 4
Louisville, KY 40222

Phone: 502-785-1005
Fax: 502-412-2258
Louisville Law Office Map

530 East Court Avenue
Jeffersonville, IN 47130

Phone: 502-785-1005
Fax: 502-412-2258
Jeffersonville Law Office Map